Parshat Miketz: Identity, Struggle, and Jewish Nation Building
By Ari Fuld HY”D
This week’s parsha, Miketz, has always been an enigma for me. Yosef’s brothers come down to Mitzrayim (Egypt) because of the famine, and Yosef recognizes them instantly, while they don’t recognize him at all. He looks different: a beard, Egyptian clothing, the whole appearance of a minister. But the real difficulty isn’t their failure to recognize him, it’s understanding what Yosef is doing to them.
He treats them harshly, accuses them of being spies, throws them in jail, detains Shimon, frames Binyamin. And we know this isn’t revenge. The Torah tells us Yosef goes into another room and cries. He doesn’t want to do this. So, what’s going on?
Yosef: Raised in Egypt, but Not an Egyptian
Yosef was taken as a teenager from the spiritual shelter of Yaakov’s home and thrown into the center of an idolatrous, immoral culture. He was given an Egyptian name – Tzafnat Paneach. He spoke Egyptian. He wore Egyptian clothing. He lived in Pharaoh’s palace.
But with all of that, Yosef never forgot who he was. He didn’t become an “Egyptian Jew,” the way people today say, “I’m an American Jew.” That’s not your identity, that’s just where you’re living geographically. Who you are is the Jew. Yosef understood that completely. Even though everything around him pushed him to become something else, he held on to his core, and that is real leadership.
Why Did Yosef Test his Brothers?
Yosef is conditioning them. These brothers are going to become the leaders of the nation of Israel, ten out of twelve tribes. They need to learn how to take care of each other. Even though they hated Yosef and sold him, they still have to learn responsibility and unity. So, Yosef puts them through this very harsh test, not to punish them, but to prepare them.
It’s similar to how we think about our children. We want them to succeed and for life to be easy. But life isn’t like pushing the Google button and getting answers right away. Real strength comes from effort and challenge. Yosef lets his brothers experience the struggle that shapes them into who they need to become.
This whole test focuses on Binyamin, the youngest brother, standing exactly where Yosef once stood. Yosef wants to see whether the brothers will stand up for him or abandon him the way they abandoned Yosef years before.
Reuven and Yehuda
When Yaakov refuses to send Binyamin back to Egypt, the brothers know they’re stuck. And now we see two very different approaches to leadership.
Reuven steps forward first. Years earlier, he suggested throwing Yosef into the pit so he could save him later without confronting the brothers directly. He wanted something that looked like leadership without taking the risk of being hated. And now again, he says what he thinks Yaakov wants to hear: “Kill my two sons if I don’t bring him back.” It sounds dramatic, but it’s empty. Yaakov already lost Yosef and Shimon, the last thing he wants to hear about is losing his grandchildren.
Reuven keeps trying to say things that sound right instead of doing the thing that is right.
Yehuda, however, steps forward calmly and takes responsibility. He tells his father plainly that he will guarantee Binyamin’s safety and bring him home. No drama. And later, when Binyamin is accused, Yehuda offers himself in his place. That is the moment Yosef needed to see.
The True Leader
The brothers grew up in the shelter of Yaakov’s home, while Yosef grew up in Egypt, completely outside that environment, and yet he never lost sight of who he was. Being a leader doesn’t come from having an easy life. It comes from making the right decisions in the hardest place, surrounded by every reason to forget who you are.
That’s why Yosef’s children, Ephraim and Menashe, become tribes of Israel. Yosef proved that a Jew can be surrounded by foreign culture, pressure, and temptation, and still remain who he is.
To be Accepted by the World
Jews want to be accepted by the world. But acceptance cannot, should not, and will not come at the expense of who we are – our identity, our history, or our land. Be a Yehuda. Be a Yosef. Don’t say what they want to hear. Be proud of who you are and what you’re supposed to be. Our identity is our strength.
Wishing everyone a wonderful, wonderful weekend. Shabbat Shalom from the stunning, beautiful rolling hills of Judea Israel. Shabbat Shalom everyone.
Edited and adapted from Ari’s Grill & Torah series.